I purchased this liner because my usual brush-tip liner by a different company was out of stock. It felt nice in my hand, easy to apply and makes very nice sharp wings. I found that throughout the day, I had to continuously wipe away smudges from my upper eyelid. It's to the point that if I wear this eyeliner, I have to check my eyelids for smudges very 15-20 minutes. I do not have oily skin and have never experienced something like this before. Buying this product was a waste of money.